Pay Scale Comparison.
Joined: 07 Sep 2009
Posted: 23 May 2011 at 4:56pm
Below is the chart comparing USPS, UPS, and FED EX. Show this to Ross!
NEWS Article. Thanks to my readers I was able to create a chart comparing Postal Service compensation to compensation at FedEx Express and United Parcel Service. As all readers know FedEx Express is non-union UPS is organized by the Teamsters and the Postal Service is organized by one of four craft unions. The Postal Service compensation figures are from 2009 and were provided by the Postal Service to reporters prior to beginning of negotiations with APWU and NRLC.
The comparison's are a bit disingenuous for the APWU includes a number of maintenance crafts that are higher paid then the most employees that sort mail. Therefore a fairer comparison would compare the average compensation of employees that sort mail or work at a retail counter with the wages paid UPS and FedEx inside workers.
The comparisons illustrates why the compensation levels negotiated with the APWU for new employees and non-career positions have much lower wages. It is clear that the new wage structure should bring APWU members that sort mail or work a retail counter to an average compensation level that will fall between what FedEx and UPS now pay. If one assumes that UPS and FedEx employees see increases in compensation in the next few years, either due to contract provisions or increases reflecting improving business at both firms, then it is possible that by the end of the contract, APWU average compensation will likely be closer to what FedEx will pay its employees than what UPS will.
In many ways, Mailhandler union members face a worse comparison that APWU members. Few of their employees are in maintenance and other positions that generate higher salaries. Therefore, their average salary is likely further above market rates than APWU members. Therefore, the contract that they will negotiate next fall will likely have all of the changes in work rules and pay schedules that the APWU just agreed to. They may find it more difficult to negotiate any protections for current employees that the APWU did.
For members of the NALC and NRLC unions the comparison is a bit more complicated. Their current compensation falls between UPS and FedEx compensation levels. However, Postal Service is seeing its volumes decline while UPS and FedEx volumes are growing. Also determining what is a fair wage for the delivery portion of the service depends on an estimate of the value of the delivery service alone and the division of revenue for all activities other than delivery and delivery. Only after that is conducted would it be clear whether the compensation paid to Postal Service carriers is at, above, or below market rates.
The difficulty of doing a comparison with compensation of the NRLC members most likely explained why the NRLC was not willing to continue to negotiate. They most likely face a lower risk of an adverse ruling in arbitration than APWU members as the economic case of the Postal Service is much more complicated in that negotiation.
Comments and suggested additions to this table are requested. They will be added to the table and posted when received.
Edited by rich1mc1 - 23 May 2011 at 4:58pm
|Forum Jump||Forum Permissions
You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot create polls in this forum
You cannot vote in polls in this forum